Hmmm I'd interject that it is sort of yes, sort of no. Intense weight training burns a lot more calories than moderate cardio exercise.
I wish PHB formatted tables naturally... view the whole thing here:
http://www.health.harvard.edu/newsweek/ ... vities.htmQuote:
Calories burned per half hour:
Gym Activity 125 pound person 155 pound person 185 pound person
Weight Lifting: general 90 112 133
Walk: 4.5 mph (13 min/mi) 150 186 222
Weight Lifting: vigorous 180 223 266
Running: 5 mph (12 min/mile) 240 298 355
Running: 5.2 mph (11.5 min/mile) 270 335 400
Running: 6 mph (10 min/mile) 300 372 444
Running: 6.7 mph (9 min/mile) 330 409 488
Running: 7.5 mph (8 min/mile) 375 465 555
Running: 8.6 mph (7 min/mile) 435 539 644
Running: 10 mph (6 min/mile) 495 614 733
As to fat burning more calories than muscle, it is neglible based on more recent research.
http://www.lanimuelrath.com/blog/calori ... -exploded/Quote:
Q: One of the more common perceptions in some fitness circles is that strength training individuals lose weight because one pound of muscle can burn approximately 30-50 calories per day. Is this claim valid?
A: It is true that muscle in its resting state is similar to an idling engine and burns energy (fuel) in the form of calories. However, according to reputable scientific research conducted on the subject, the actual number of calories burned by a pound of resting muscle in a day is considerably less than 50.
In fact, the caloric expenditure that can be attributed to lean muscle mass is not very significant. For example, muscle tissue has been observed to burn roughly seven to 10 calories per pound per day, compared to two to three calories per pound per day for fat. Therefore, if you replace a pound of fat with a pound of muscle, you can expect to burn only approximately four to six more calories a day. Given the fact that the average person who strength trains typically gains approximately 3 to 5 pounds of muscle mass over a period of three to four months, the net caloric effect of such a training regimen is very modest-only 15 to 30 calories per day (the equivalent of a few potato chips).
With that said, much like Lenas, I prefer weight-training infinitely to cardio. Not only do you feel "ripped" but adding muscle adds structural support which reduces sagginess, bulges, etc. Just by doing shoulders I have fixed a lifelong slouch which makes me look taller and more confident and (at least appear to be) generally more healthy. Plus over the long-haul I will still eventually reach my target weight.
_________________
Quote:
In comic strips the person on the left always speaks first. - George Carlin