RangerDave wrote:
So is the overwhelming criticism of the game itself (not just the PC port) legit or overblown?
This trailer? Overblown but with a couple good elements of truth to it. Yes, Sean Murray outright lied about a few things the trailer mentioned. If those happened to be your reason for buying the game, then the rage is justified. Space combat does seem kind of boring. There aren't differences in ships beyond how they look. Yes, factions are mostly meaningless in their current form. Inventory management is ridiculous early on, but I think that's more a testament to poor tutorial and not knowing what things you should carry early on (hint: it's not titanium, nickel, shielding plates, or power cells).
The heart and soul of this game is exploration. I've been on the same planet for about 10 hours now. Not because I'm stuck, but because I keep finding cool crap (and making good money too!). I keep coming back to the comparison between this game and ME1. People loved or hated the Mako. I felt it embodied the pioneering theme of the game and I explored literally (and by literally, I don't mean figuratively) every planet getting every possible discovery off of them. If you hated driving around in the Mako, you're probably going to hate NMS. For some people, simply reaching the top of the hill to see what's beyond is it's own reward. I'm one of them.
I agree with the "honest" trailer this game should not cost $60. The game is too simple for that price point. But I'd willingly pay $30 for it. Once it goes on sale, I will buy it and relinquish my *ahem* demo version.