Xequecal wrote:
Diamondeye wrote:
Not at all. Territorial expansion on our own continent is hardly incompatible with isolationism in regard to the rest of the world. Seeing it as an act of aggression to start new colonies in our part of the world contributes ot isolationsim; it's not the opposite of it.
This country was mostly isolationist from the end of the War of 1812 until the Spanish American War and WWI.
It is when the land is owned by another country. You're invading them. This is not isolationist. Having a body of water between you and the country you're invading doesn't somehow make it different.
Yes, actually it does. Isolationism comes in degrees. It's not a matter of "you're isolationist if and only if you absolutely avoid foreign engagement of any kind or description."
Aside from the fact that the concept of "land ownership" held by the Indian tribes was of questionable similarity to what we regard as "ownership" in the first place (which I'm sure varied significantly from tribe to tribe; let's not get caught up in minutae), the fact is that a country that shares a land border with you is nearly impossible to engage in "isolationism" from; look at the impossibility of completely sealing off the MExican border, and that's with a river in the way for around half of the border and the industrial ability to create large walls and fence and deploy thousands of law enforcement agents, plus soldiers, aircraft, and if we wanted to, tanks and artillery. Therefore saying "having a body of water in the way doesn't make it different" is utterly idiotic; of course it does. That body of water is, in a large part, what makes isolationism possible
at all.
Second, discussing whether the U.S. was "isolationist" means in the context of the world in general. In regard to the world in general, we were. The fact that we were bust conquering land directly adjacent to our own doesn't somehow mean that our overall policy was anything other than isolationist.
Overall, that was the general gist of our policy until it finally died from German torpedo fire. Isolationism is a matter of degrees, not a matter of "ZOMG you have to meet all this criteria to qualify!"