RangerDave wrote:
Diamondeye wrote:
Sort of. It also shows Democratic exploitation of identity politics.
The Republicans have been exploiting identity politics every bit as much for the last 50 years. They just target white, Christian and male identity politics.
The Republicans have been exploiting Democratic exploitation of identity politics. The Democrat strategy has been to create special benefits, privileges, and protections based on identity groups on the basis that they're needed to remedy past inequalities - but then never admit to any actual improvement created by these efforts, and simply demand more of them. They garner support for this by painting any opposition as "racist" or "sexist", and then when people (rightly) resent being called racist or sexist, or resent the caricature of an "equal" society where groups get permanent special privileges based on an ever-shifting definition of oppression, the Democrats invariably claim that it's all about the bigotry these groups supposedly possess - while ignoring or excusing much more open bigotry within their own groups.
So yes, the Republicans have been appealing to the effect that the combination of open hypocrisy and blatant goalpost-shifting creates among whites, males, and Christians - and they would not be able to do this had the Democrats ever embraced actual equality instead of a perpetual cycle of victimhood. The identity politics you claim the Republicans are exploiting are a product of the Democrats' tactics - they are not a desire to return to some 1950s or before state; almost no one thinks that's either achievable or desirable no matter how nostalgic they might appear. That generation is either elderly or dead.
I'm sure you'll try to contest this, but you said it yourself "The last 50 years". 50 years ago was the combination of civil rights legislation and the Great Society/War on Poverty. Lyndon Johnson really cared about neither - he saw a way to buy votes. It's stayed that way for 50 years, and the left is addicted to the idea that there's perpetual oppression that needs to be fought and knows no other way to put forth a message. Working-class voters with jobs like coal mining and manufacturing haven't gone Republican because of identity politics by Republicans; they've gone that way because they've realized the Democrats have paid lip service to their economic concerns on one hand while pushing trade deals and calling them racists on the other.
Bernie Sanders even fell afoul of this - he actually got arrested protesting for civil rights as a much younger man, but he framed his message in economic terms, and as a result he was attacked for having a support base (and representing a state) that was "too white." The Democratic party is terrified of having to deal with politics that do not contain a strong identity component - they literally
do not know how; the politicians that did are all dead, or are Jimmy Carter's age. The irony is that if they did change, the Republicans wouldn't know what to do either. The Republicans have just started figuring out that their own voters have no more patience for this nonsense, and want someone to actually stand up to it - something the average person could have told them 25 years ago, but it took Donald Trump to finally get them to maybe start pulling their heads at least partway out of their asses.