Yes Khross, really:
Forgive me for the following lengthy post, but I believe a statistical comparison is necessary. First I will address the points you've raised in your post, and then build on them.
Quote:
Maddux has more decisions, more complete games, more shut outs.
Actually, Maddux does have more decisions then Clemens but not in any way that bolsters your argument. Despite having only one more career win than Clemens, and only 33 more career starts than Clemens, Maddux has a staggering 43 more losses (227 - 184) yielding a career winning percentage a sizeable .048 lower than Clemens' (.658 - .610). On complete games and shutouts you are just plain wrong. While from a single season leader standpoint the two are very comparable: Clemens having led the league in complete games three times and shutouts six times, against Maddux's three and five respectively, however over the course of their careers Clemens completed 118 games against Maddux's 109, and shutout his opponent 46 times (26th all-time) against Maddux's 35 (71st all-time).
Quote:
And 3 Walks and 9 Strike Outs per 9 is a vastly different ratio than 2 walks and 6 strike outs per 9.
It absolutely matters when calling one person a power pitcher, and the other a control artist, and making that the necessary distinction between the two. The metric used to evaluate power vs. control is the strikeout to walk ratio. The per 9 doesn't matter in this instance. The power/control is equal. The only other factor that matters is WHIP ratio (walks+hits/innings pitched) Clemens has a career WHIP of 1.173, against Maddux's slightly better yet negligible 1.143. Infact, Maddux actually allowed 70 more base runners than Clemens of the course of their careers.
Quote:
seeing as Greg Maddux has the lowest career base runners allowed of any pitcher in the top 10.
Actually, Maddux ranks 53rd on the all-time leader board for WHIP. Notable names ahead of Maddux? Walter Johnson, Christy Matthewson, Chief Bender, Tom Seaver, Sandy Koufax,Cy Young himself, and a host of other Hall of Famers including even Don Sutton. Clemens places 87th, far far ahead of actual power pitcher Nolan Ryan whose career WHIP is 1.247.
Clemens comes out ahead of Maddux in virtually ever single category that matters:
Clemens won seven ERA titles (second all-time behind only Lefty Grove with ten) to Maddux's four, and actually holds an lifetime unadjusted ERA of 3.12 against Maddux's 3.16. When we consider adjusted ERA (the more valuable statistical metric) Clemens' dominance becomes even more apparent as he holds eight seasonal titles against Maddux's five, and ranks tenth all-time, a full 24 spots ahead of Maddux who's life time benefits of pitching in the National League are stripped away by the statistic.
Clemens has six 20 win seasons, Maddux has two. Clemens played in twelve seasons in which he won at least 17 games against Maddux's ten. Clemens led the league in wins four times compared to Maddux's three, and despite starting 33 fewer career games, a full season's worth, than Maddux (740-707), pitching almost 100 fewer innings than Maddux (5008.1 - 4916.2), and playing on worse teams than Maddux, Clemens won only one less game than Maddux over the course of their careers (355 - 354).
Clemens led the league in strikeouts five times, a feat Maddux never accomplished once. And while you are pigeonholing "The Rocket" as a power pitcher because of his strikeout totals, remember that Greg Maddux is a member of the very exclusive 3000 strikeout club with 3371 K's in his career, which ranks him tenth all-time, only seven spots behind Clemens who ranks third.
Clemens won seven Cy Youngs (that's the all-time leader in the category) against Maddux's four, and while Maddux won four in a row (I will concede that Maddux was the better pitcher of the two between 1992 and 1995), a feat duplicated by Randy Johnson, Clemens won at least two in three different decades while no one else in history has won even one in three demonstrating that Clemens was the better pitcher from 1988-2007 (the overlap of their careers).
_________________
Quote:
19 Yet she became more and more promiscuous as she recalled the days of her youth, when she was a prostitute in Egypt. 20 There she lusted after her lovers, whose genitals were like those of donkeys and whose emission was like that of horses.
Ezekiel 23:19-20