Rorinthas wrote:
As for Steven, I'll say the same thing as I tell everyone else. If you're right you'll never know. You won't even have the opportunity to say "I told you so." If you're wrong, you'll find out someday. Of course my Bible says by then it's too late to do anything about it. If he's comfortable with that that's his business.
Ah, but what if you're both wrong? What if the Sunni muslims are right? Wait, what if the Shia muslims are right? Oh no, perhaps the Sufi Muslims. Or the Westboro Baptist Church? Or any of hundreds of various religious faiths that all hold that if you do not follow their exact faith, you'll suffer damnation?
See, I've seen Dawkins asked what you just asked: "What if you're wrong?" He may very well be wrong. Dawkins is a bit more dogmatic than I like. But him being wrong doesn't make you right. This isn't a binary thing. One cannot live in fear of being wrong about that which nobody can prove. You simply believe what looks right, and hope that any God that may exist isn't as monstrously evil as the one christians worship. As for Heaven, Hawking's right about one thing - it has a lot in common with a "fairy story." The weight of evidence is equal for the possibility that there are Faeries in my garden. I rather like the idea, actually. I tell my daughter to watch for them, just in case our ancestors were right about them. God is a faerie story -- a tale told to explain natural wonders which man could not account for. It's possible those stories were right, even now that we can account for them. I won't live my life hedging bets on such things, though. There are an infinite number of faerie stories we'd have to worry about.
*throws salt over her shoulder.*