Eh? I'm seeing almost nothing but good to great ones (aside from Gamespot and IGN, but meh).
Kotaku:"To say that
Isolation is superior to
Colonial Marines is really just to affirm that, no, it is not one of the worst games I've ever played. Good news, though! Even considered without the Alien brand,
Isolation is a very good time. It's equal parts
Worst-Case Situation Simulator 2014 and
"**** Everything!": The Game. It does have some significant flaws, but on the whole, it works."
The Verge:"The good news is that Isolation largely achieves what it set out to do despite these issues. This is a game that makes you feel like Sigourney Weaver in the first Alien film: scared, alone, and constantly on edge. I've never been so terrified by a game, for so long. No matter how many times I encountered the alien, I never felt comfortable in its presence. You need to put up with some frustratingly bland sequences to enjoy all of the good stuff, but it’s worth it.
Isolation is so close to being the Alien game I always wanted that I don’t mind a few sequences where I’m forced to shoot androids with a shotgun."
The Guardian:"This terrifying game is a passionate homage to a horror classic, and a rich, well-designed stealth experience in its own right. Giger’s monstrous alien is, for the first time in a video game, as formidable and menacing as it was in the films. It was brave of Sega to take a chance on a game like this, where guns are a last resort, but their faith in The Creative Assembly’s vision has resulted in an unusually clever and subversive triple-A game."
Xbox Magazine:"And that's the triumph of
Alien: Isolation. It takes all the diluting clutter the series has accrued over the past 35 years, shoves them all into a bag, opens the airlock and jettisons them into the blackness of space. All that remains is all that was ever needed - you, the alien and an enormous playground to play hide-and-seek in. The result is a rarity among videogames - an adventure that perfectly reproduces the foreboding, psychological terror of cinema horror and is filled with tense moments that will keep your heart racing long after the screen fades to black."
And the laundry list that they're trumpeting:
“The game the Alien series has always deserved. A deep, fun stealth game set in an evocatively realised sci-fi world.”
93% - PC GAMER
“A total-immersion simulation of the film, with all of the horror, cruelty, disempowerment, and desperate, hard-fought triumphs that entails.”
9/10 - GAMESRADAR
“This terrifying game is a passionate homage to a horror classic, and a rich, well-designed stealth experience in its own right.”
5/5 - THE GUARDIAN
"Unique stealth-horror thriller that combines great pacing and smart design with razor-sharp AI."
9/10 - OFFICIAL XBOX MAGAZINE
“Scary and defiantly difficult, Alien: Isolation represents the triumphant return of proper survival horror to AAA gaming.”
9/10 - XBOX ACHIEVEMENTS
"CA has finally nailed the true terror of
Alien in video game form."
9/10 - VIDEOGAMER -
“A masterpiece”
90% - PLAY
“Creative Assembly has given us a creature to be feared again, and delivered the scariest game of the year. Prepare to scream.”
5/5 - EMPIRE MAGAZINE
"
Alien: Isolation is a phenomenal title."
9/10 - GOD IS A GEEK
"The Alien is scarier than it's been since Ridley Scott first showed it to the world, and the atmosphere is thick enough to cut."
4.5/5 - THE ESCAPIST