Screeling wrote:
I saw it in IMAX 3D up in San Diego over the weekend. I really dug it. I didn't walk in with huge expectations. I'm rarely expecting the best storyline outta movies these days so when it's half way decent, or a good copy of a story I already liked, I'm usually satisfied.
Seeing it in 3D didn't really do much for me though. It almost seemed like the image quality was worse because of it.
The thing that bothers me about 3D movies is, you can add all the stereopsis and convergence you want with the 3D cameras and rendering, but they're still limited by the depth of field they can achieve.
In other words, you can make the soldiers between me and the Colonel look between me and the Colonel, but I still can't choose to look at them properly, because they're out of focus. I imagine someday, we'll have shrunk the cameras down even more, to allow for simultaneous shooting of multiple focal lengths from near-identical sets of binocular perspectives, and then composite them together in some kind of complex post-processing system (this is actually easier for computer renders, because you can simply render everything in focus rather than imposing depth of field effects upon you render to get it to blend in with the live photography).
Of course, this'll create a NEW problem, in that now everything's too sharp, when your eye is accustomed to having things you're not focusing (binocularly speaking) on falling out of monocular focus because they really are at a different depth, while you can't rely on images projected on a flat screen to do so. So we'll also have to move from dual projected images with glasses to selectively view them, to a system that will track an individual's eye movements and adjust the rendering (inserting the depth of field blur) in response to where in the image we're tracking our stereoptic convergence.
Until then, I can't help but find even our very good 3D a little distracting, particularly in scenes where I either want to "visually explore" them (like I found I was with a lot of the vistas of Pandora), or when I get a bit bored of the focus-guided action and stray from it unintentionally.