TheRiov wrote:
A) genital mutilation is not a religious thing. It's cultural and includes a number of Christian majority countries.
That's like pointing out that Christmas Trees are technically cultural. It isn't Christian immigrants importing this practice into Western democracies.
Quote:
B) honor killings are hardly the sole purview of Islam exist in many cultures historically including Christianity.
They are not today practiced by Christians, and again, are not taking place among Christian immigrants to Western countries - and in point of fact were never as widespread among Christians; women who got honor killed in Islam got sent to convents in the west.
Quote:
C) the religious right has been pushing their own version of Sharia law for 1500 years
the religious right is an entirely modern concept, existing exclusively post-WWII at the earliest. The idea that anyone was "promoting Sharia" in times when the concept of science and the ability to practice it were yet to be developed (to say nothing ot eh total lack of tools to do it with) is an absurd distortion of history. People are quick to complain about "Creationism" but demanding that people in the past be held to the standards of today is essentially the same thing. Modernity could not spring of its own accord onto the scene; a species evolving from hunter-gatherer ancestors after billions of years of planetary development had to evolve the concepts we enjoy today. So no, you do not get to trot out the "Sharia" of 500 AD and pretend its the same as immigrants today coming into a society that has rejected that and complain about it.
Oh, and while we're at it, the Western "sharia" of even the last 500 years was still pretty preferable to what much of Islam practices today.
Quote:
So don't try to pretend this is about the evils of one religion.
I'm not pretending. It IS about the evils of one religion. Dragging up the practices of Christians centuries ago to excuse Muslims doing it today is simply a double standard intended to give Muslims a free pass. Western Christian nations have been moving farther and farther away from this, to the degree that for the last 30 years its been victory after victory for secularism, to the point that the secularists are among those (such as civil rights advocates and feminists) who have largely run out of battles to fight and decided to invent problems to solve.
Islam is not, and they don't have the excuse of living in a world where science doesn't even exist
Quote:
You asked for why someone would see parallels. I gave you the answer. You just don't want to admit you're complicit in this perversion of American ideals.
I'm not "complicit" in any such thing, because no such ideal ever existed to pervert. This is part of the problem - the left wants to invent "ideals" wholesale, assign them a historical status they never actually had, try to shame people for not slavishly agreeing to this nonsense.
The fact of the matter is that the religious group you're talking about is responsible for repeated attacks on America and the West over the last decades that no other group even begins to approach. You think it's unfair to look at them all suspiciously to find the one that's going to blow up? You want to treat them as individuals?
All right. Then stop treating blacks as a singular interest group. Stop it with white people, women, men, Hispanics, Asians, and literally everyone else. The left is standing around in dumbfounded shock that it just lost an election because white women (in part) didn't slavishly vote for the white woman. Turns out white women can think! Who knew?!? Maybe treating them as a whole block wasn't such a great idea?
Identity politics is the toy of the left; and you just don't like it when it gets turned back on you. You only want to demand "individuality" when it helps you. When it doesn't help you, all of aa sudden it's "perverting American ideals" just because people might want to check and make sure the minority you want to import so you can stand there in total shock when they don't vote 100% Democrat in the next election doesn't occasionally blow up a train station. This isn't about American idealsl; this is about the Left wanting to manipulate demographics for political advantage, and try to pretend real issues don't exist because it might offend the people that should "ALLAHU ACKBAR!!!" at the TV set every time someone stabs an old lady on the streets in Israel.